Seeing Like a State

How Certain Schemes to Improve the Human Condition Have Failed

by James C. Scott · 2020 · 480 pages · Yale University Press

Cover of Seeing Like a State

Is Seeing Like a State worth reading?

Reception: Acclaimed · Historical critique of top-down state planning

Seeing Like a State is a sharp, wide-ranging critique of how governments and planners try to reshape societies from above, often with disastrous results. Scott ranges from Russian collective farms to Tanzanian villages and Brasília, showing how simplified standards such as surnames, censuses and standard measures can erase local knowledge.

Who is Seeing Like a State for?

Content warnings in Seeing Like a State

None noted.

What do critics and readers say about Seeing Like a State?

“Although I am in sympathy with Scott’s diagnosis of the development disasters he recounts, I conclude that he has not burrowed deep enough to discover a systematic cause of these failures.”

The Independent Review, Deepak Lal (via Wikipedia)

Readers

Readers tend to praise the book's clear, engaging prose and its memorable examples, which make abstract ideas about planning and legibility easy to grasp. Some find the argument sweeping and selective in its evidence, and others feel its critique of state planning leaves open how alternatives should work.

What is Seeing Like a State about?

“One of the most profound and illuminating studies of this century to have been published in recent decades.”—John Gray, New York Times Book Review “A powerful, and in many [ways] insightful, explanation as to why grandiose programs of social reform, not to mention revolution, so often end in tragedy. . . . An important critique of visionary state planning.”—Robert Heilbroner, Lingua Franca Hailed as “a magisterial critique of top-down social planning” by the New York Times, this essential work analyzes disasters from Russia to Tanzania to uncover why states so often fail—sometimes catastrophically—in grand efforts to engineer their society or their environment, and uncovers the conditions common to all such planning disasters. “Beautifully written, this book calls into sharp relief the nature of the world we now inhabit.”—New Yorker “A tour de force.”— Charles Tilly, Columbia University

About James C. Scott

James C. Scott (1936–2024) was an American political scientist and anthropologist who taught at Yale University for many years, where he was Sterling Professor of Political Science and Anthropology. He is best known for studies of peasant resistance and the relationship between states and the societies they govern.

Scott's other notable works include Weapons of the Weak: Everyday Forms of Peasant Resistance and The Art of Not Being Governed, both drawing on fieldwork and historical research. His writing combines close attention to ordinary people's practices with broad comparative argument.

Sources: Wikipedia (English) · Google Books · Open Library. Wikipedia text is available under CC BY-SA 4.0.

ToBeRead: find out if a book is for you, keep notes while you read, and remember what you read.